CALL 205.538.3340

The Law Office of J.D. Lloyd Logo Because There’s Hope After the Trial


After The Trial Blog

The After The Trial blog presents insights on ongoing and recent trials around the state of Alabama, including weekly criminal law round-ups.

Alabama Death-Row Inmates Ask for SCOTUS Review

J.D. Lloyd - Friday, January 06, 2017

Today, the US Supreme Court is considering three cert petitions involving important questions challenging the Alabama capital sentencing scheme. Two challenges involve the Supreme Court’s 2016 ruling in Hurst v. Florida, which held that any fact necessary to expose a defendant to the death penalty must be found by a jury, not a judge.


Two cert petitions involve Tommy Arthur, a man who’s been on Alabama’s death row for 30 years. One petition is a Hurst-based challenge. In that petition, Arthur (1) makes a general challenge to Alabama’s scheme under Hurst; (2) argues Hurst requires a unanimous jury vote for death (his vote for death was 11-1); and (3) claims Hurst applies retroactively.


Arthur’s second petition raises Eighth Amendment claims against Alabama’s execution protocol.


The Court is also considering a cert petition from Jerry Bohannon. While I do not have a copy of Bohannon’s cert petition, I would imagine he is raising claims similar to those he presented to the Alabama Supreme Court in his case that was decided in September 2016. There, the Court rejected a number of Hurst claims, most notably Bohannon’s challenge that Hurst requires a jury to decide the weight of aggravating factors against mitigating factors.


In Alabama, a judge makes the final sentencing determination and must decide that the aggravating factors of a case outweigh the mitigating factors in order to sentence a defendant to death. Under Alabama law (which is grounded in pre-Aprendi/Ring SCOTUS decisions), the weighing of aggravators versus mitigators is purely a job for the judge, not the jury. A fairly clear and long line of cases has held that the Sixth Amendment does not require a jury to conduct this weighing. Hurst calls this thinking into question.


I’m bearish on either case’s chance. I think Arthur has a better shot on the Eighth Amendment issue than the Sixth Amendment issue, but I don’t think he’d have the votes to do anything. Bohannon’s weighing claim is somewhat blunted by the fact that the jury recommended death by a vote of 11-1, so whatever error he claims might be harmless. Moreover, I don’t believe he raised a claim that Hurst requires juror unanimity, which probably would have helped. The Court should wait on a better vehicle – an override case - to take that issue up.


However, should the Court take up Bohannon’s case on the weighing issue, I think there’s a good chance the Court would rule in Bohannon’s favor and hold that the Sixth Amendment requires a jury to determine the weight of aggravators versus mitigators. I think the votes are there. Ginsburg authored Ring, Sotomayor wrote a scathing dissent in the denial of cert in Woodward v. AL, a case that challenged override in the pre-Hurst era, Breyer believes the Eighth Amendment requires a jury to find everything (even if he doesn’t like Ring) and joined Sotomayor’s dissent in Woodward, and Kagan, Kennedy, Thomas and Roberts were in the majority in Hurst.


Even if the Court doesn’t take up one of these two cases, I believe the writing is on the wall that the Court will be forced to take a closer look at Alabama’s capital sentencing scheme either this term or next.



If you or someone you know has been convicted of wrongful criminal charges, there is hope after the trial. Contact us today by clicking HERE.



Recent Posts


drug busts lamar county dekalb county alabama decatur alabama street racing mobile alabama adger alabama fourth amendment felony assaults cherokee county alabama Rule 32 lethal injection gadsden alabama theft talladega superspeedway peyton pruitt madison alabama trussville alabama illegal gambling Gardendale Alabama sentencing law and policy blog summaries brendan dassey, steve avery, making a murderer, scotus, netflix burglary hoover alabama warrior alabama fairfield alabama, unlawful manufacturing baldwin county alabama smith v state dora alabama home repair fraud court of criminal appeal releases shoplifting church robberies greene county alabama morris alabama Tommy Arthur hoax destructive devices forced isolation brookside alabama fraudulent checks drug activity stoves v state road rage sexual assault brendan dassey OJ Simpson Made in America animal cruelty montgomery alabama Glaze v State Easter William Pryor blount county alabama kidnapping Briarwood Presbyterian Church birchfield v north dakota tuscaloosa alabama illegal gun carry armed robbery betton v state russell calhoun warrantless blood draws negligent homicide eugene lee jones v state state of alabama breaking and entering Fentanyl Alonzo Ephraim domestic violence economic growth ex parte briseno US Supreme Court Update steve avery drug possession, assault CCA update pelham alabama OJ Simpson death penalty avondale alabama morgan county alabama st clair county alabama eleventh circuit ruling texas hurst mandamus gun rights abuse Adamsville alabama blountsville alabama ring v arizona arson lauderdale county alabama criminal justice mcwilliams v dunn heritage christian university Kareem Dacar Gaymon bailey v us ferguson missouri towles v state Neil Gorsuch eighth amendment, public assistance fraud Thomas Hardiman homicide rate Alabaster alabama Lucky D Arcade brian fredick lucas sarah koenig serial scotus operation bullseye shooting death foley alabama Woods v State shelby county bomb threat parole christian guitierez drug crimes death penalty, fultondale alabama self defense prostitution sting capital murder Ingmire v State mountain brook alabama § 13A-3-23 levins v state drug seizure fake kidnapping, attempted murder hall v florida aiding and abetting editorial Benn v State Guy Terrell Junior alabama albertville alabama Marengo County Alabama making a murderer criminal mischief mount olive alabama Dylann Roof alabama criminal law roundup fort payne alabama judicial override rainbow city alabama hurst v florida christmas shooting capital punishment jerry bohannon domestic abuse aziz sayyed bernard v north dakota debit card skimming scams huntsville huntsville alabama murder abduction heflin alabama Tracie Todd boaz alabama 28 U.S.C. § 2254 Jefferson County Alabama § 13A-3-23(d) immunity hearing alabama supreme court shooting oneonta alabama maryland court of special appeals utah v strieff florence alabama second amendment Donald Trump, LWOP constitutional violations edwards v arizona minor offenses stanley brent chapman john earle redfearn IV v state midazolam kenneth eugene billups moore v texas drug trafficking, asia mcclain Etowah County Alabama, concealed carry pell city alabama Malone v State brady v maryland apprendi v new jersey criminal justice reform, south carolina marion county legende v state lethal injection drugs sixth amendment car accident Joshua Reese fraud Eutaw Alabama Justice Sotomayor Xavier Beasley mccalla alabama limestone county alabama New York Times Kay Ivey Wesley Adam Whitworth birmingham alabama tarrant alabama identity theft hanceville alabama npr department of justice executions debtor prison state of arizona West Alabama benjamin todd acton underage drinking pinson alabama mulga alabama SCOTUS, 2016 election, banville v state utah supreme court endangerment of a child calhoun county alabama crime of passion Pleasant Grove Alabama Walker County Alabama strickland v washington Shonda Walker, Mike Hubbard campbell v state robberies mike gilotti ake v oklahoma court systems, embezzlement bessemer alabama theft of property court of criminal appeals alabama law enforcement agency abandonment sheffield v state homicide social media anniston alabama, habeas corpus relief operation crackdown baltimore city circuit court eric sterling keith v state constitutional law, dothan alabama pruitt v state nathan woods Hillary Clinton, the mannequin challenge implied consent alfonso morris clarence thomas netflix department of justice, nicholas hawkins narcotics investigation gun control battles v state cullman alabama Stephen Breyer Samuel Alito moving violations terell corey mcmullin Sardis Alabama drug smuggling springville alabama adnan syed, kimberly alabama beylund v north dakota capital offenses



These recoveries and testimonials are not an indication of future results. Every case is different, and regardless of what friends, family, or other individuals may say about what a case is worth, each case must be evaluated on its own facts and circumstances as they apply to the law. The valuation of a case depends on the facts, the injuries, the jurisdiction, the venue, the witnesses, the parties, and the testimony, among  other factors. Furthermore, no representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.

Get Free Legal Advice  Contact us for a complimentary legal consultation

I am interested in scheduling a free legal consultation and receiving additional information.

Submitting Form...

The server encountered an error.

Thank you, your  entry has been  received.

© 2017 The Law Office of J.D. Lloyd, LLC. All Rights Reserved. |


As required by Rule 7.2(e), Alabama Rules of Professional Conduct, no representation is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.